There is an interesting debate that has been percolating in more than just a few school districts lately.
Basically, there are some school districts in this country, with vastly different levels of family income within its boundaries. Some schools within a particular district may receive Title I funds from the federal government to help with low-income families, while other schools in the same district may have a much higher level of income among its families.
The problem is that schools with wealthier families are typically able to raise more money than schools with less well-to-do families. Therefore, the students in these schools can go on more field trips, have newer text books, have more interesting assemblies, and have newer technology. (The richer schools have more parents who will buy tubs of cookie dough, tickets to an auction, make pledges for a walk-a-thon, etc.)
Well, there have been complaints that the educational experience of the students in the poorer school is less complete than the students in the richer schools, and this is not fair in a public school district.
Therefore, some districts are creating plans to take the money raised by all their schools, put it in a common pot, and re-distribute it equally amongst all schools, regardless of how much each school kicked in. This way, all students will get the same opportunities.
This proposal is not sitting well with many people. In fact, here is an excerpt from a letter to the editor in The Santa Monica (California) Mirror:
Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District Fundraising Efforts: Letter To The School Board
Dear School Board,
I can’t even begin to tell you how disappointed I am with your recent decision to combine the fundraising efforts for the schools into one system. I understand that there is an achievement gap in our schools; I believe that is why some of them receive Title 1 funds. I also understand that many of those funds have been cut, but not all. Will those resources also be allocated equally among all schools in the district?
I work hard to support my school, sacrificing valuable time and resources. And I’m not ashamed to admit that this is primarily because I have two children in the Santa Monica school system. I want to support them as much as humanly possible, which is easy to do when I get to see how my efforts affect their lives on a daily basis.
Would I work just as hard knowing that my time and money might go to other schools in the district? I’m honestly not sure. But the fact that I’m even asking myself the question just goes to show how wrong-headed your decision is.
While I believe that combining some of the resources from the wealthier schools could help, creating a system that equally distributes funds to all schools will only result in an overall decrease in the number of donations. On the surface, it would seem your plan is plausible — a simple and fair redistribution of funds — but this assumes that you’ll receive the same amount of money. Sadly, this is not the case.
The first rule of fundraising is to appeal to the donor’s sense of social responsibility and community. Put simply, people give more to causes that are personal or “hit close to home.” By broadening the spectrum of how school funds will be distributed, the board will have effectively narrowed its fundraising target and legislated a major disincentive to donations, especially with regard to your top-tier donors. Just imagine what would happen if college alumni associations were forced to distributed their donations to all universities instead of the college of their choice.
It’s just that simple.
My friends and neighbors have all expressed that they will not continue to monitarily support the schools in the same manner. We have not only discussed this in the hallways of our schools, but also with incoming parents. In fact I spoke to a friend on Monday about this new effort on the part of the school board. She was planning to move her family to Santa Monica, and has now decided to stay in Brentwood. So I know I’m not alone. Luckily, I am the treasurer of my child’s class, so next year I plan on asking for more money upfront to support our teacher rather than fundraising for the district.
So, how do you feel about this debate? Do you agree that all schools within one district should be able to give all its students that same opportunities, or is it ok for there to be a large gap between rich and poor schools?
I’d love to know what your thoughts are. Please share them with us in our forum!
Thanks!
Photo by: WebWallpapers
No Comments »